But the fact that TCPStreams isa file-descriptor, Files isa file-descriptor, Pipes isa file-descriptor, and other such “stream-like objects” in the Linux kernel proves that the read/recv and write/send system calls are generic enough to work in a wide variety of circumstances.
Yeah, they’re all different. But as far as the Linux API goes, they’re all file descriptors under it all and have abstractions that work well for inheritance in practice. In many cases, inheritance doesn’t work. But in many cases, it works. And works well, for decades.
Inheritance here is limiting. Composition creates a far nicer API. Take both go and rust, they use a set of different interfaces/traits that cover, Reader, Writer, Closer, Seeker. Not everything implements all of these and can implement any set of them. For instance, a File implements them all, as it can be read from, be written to, closed and arbitrarily seeked. But a TCP Stream cannot random seek to other locations inside it - you cannot suddenly reset a network connection to the start again, those bytes are lost. So even if they are both file deciphers they do have different behaviours.
And these can be used for more than just files and network connections - you can write into or read from a vector/list of bytes, even seek randomly into it, but cannot close it as that does not make any sense.
Most languages cannot have multiple inheritance - so you are stuck with a abstract class with all the functions on it with blank implementations so the unsupported functions become no-ops. But IMO that is just a hack to workaround the lack of being able to split these different types up.
Man, I honestly have no idea why they are downvoting you. Composition literally means taking common behavior and placing it in external objects behind interfaces using a has-a relationship.
No idea why they are denying this. Inheritance vs composition is the same as “is-a” vs “has-a”. In composition re usability isn’t done via inheritance but code encapsulation.
Saying that in Go objects can implement many interfaces is the Interface Segregation principle from SOLID. Basically having small interfaces instead of a big interface with methods that may not be implemented by all implementors.
You’re confusing polymorphism for inheritance. read is a method on an interface that File implements - it is not inherited from a base class. You can use that File directly, or wherever a Reader interface (or whatever the name is, idk I don’t really do Go) is expected.
You are not logged in. However you can subscribe from another Fediverse account, for example Lemmy or Mastodon. To do this, paste the following into the search field of your instance: !programming@programming.dev
Welcome to the main community in programming.dev! Feel free to post anything relating to programming here!
Cross posting is strongly encouraged in the instance. If you feel your post or another person’s post makes sense in another community cross post into it.
Hope you enjoy the instance!
Rules
Rules
Follow the programming.dev instance rules
Keep content related to programming in some way
If you’re posting long videos try to add in some form of tldr for those who don’t want to watch videos
But the fact that TCPStreams isa file-descriptor, Files isa file-descriptor, Pipes isa file-descriptor, and other such “stream-like objects” in the Linux kernel proves that the read/recv and write/send system calls are generic enough to work in a wide variety of circumstances.
Yeah, they’re all different. But as far as the Linux API goes, they’re all file descriptors under it all and have abstractions that work well for inheritance in practice. In many cases, inheritance doesn’t work. But in many cases, it works. And works well, for decades.
Inheritance here is limiting. Composition creates a far nicer API. Take both go and rust, they use a set of different interfaces/traits that cover, Reader, Writer, Closer, Seeker. Not everything implements all of these and can implement any set of them. For instance, a File implements them all, as it can be read from, be written to, closed and arbitrarily seeked. But a TCP Stream cannot random seek to other locations inside it - you cannot suddenly reset a network connection to the start again, those bytes are lost. So even if they are both file deciphers they do have different behaviours.
And these can be used for more than just files and network connections - you can write into or read from a vector/list of bytes, even seek randomly into it, but cannot close it as that does not make any sense.
Most languages cannot have multiple inheritance - so you are stuck with a abstract class with all the functions on it with blank implementations so the unsupported functions become no-ops. But IMO that is just a hack to workaround the lack of being able to split these different types up.
You’re not describing composition.
Go Files do not “hasa reader”. You don’t do file.reader.read(), you just do file.read(), that’s inheritance as file has inherited the read() method.
Composition do not necessitate the creation of a new field like x.reader or x.writer, what are you on?
https://www.infoworld.com/article/3409071/java-challenger-7-debugging-java-inheritance.html#toc-2
composition is literally the “has a” relationship. That’s how its always been taught.
Man, I honestly have no idea why they are downvoting you. Composition literally means taking common behavior and placing it in external objects behind interfaces using a has-a relationship.
No idea why they are denying this. Inheritance vs composition is the same as “is-a” vs “has-a”. In composition re usability isn’t done via inheritance but code encapsulation.
Saying that in Go objects can implement many interfaces is the Interface Segregation principle from SOLID. Basically having small interfaces instead of a big interface with methods that may not be implemented by all implementors.
You’re confusing polymorphism for inheritance.
readis a method on an interface thatFileimplements - it is not inherited from a base class. You can use thatFiledirectly, or wherever aReaderinterface (or whatever the name is, idk I don’t really do Go) is expected.