A better "All" browsing experience for small Lemmy instances - GitHub - jheidecker/lemmony: A better "All" browsing experience for small Lemmy instances
The idea of this app, which is desperately needed, is to allow those of us that are running a very small private instance to still get access to all of the communities. If you have a decent user base then you don’t need this anymore as the users themselves will provide the functionality.
So in my case I am the only user on my instance so I am certainly not going to be hammering a bunch of instances just to send me updates of whatever total number of communities I’m subscribed to.
I also wanted something like this, but I don’t want every single community. I ended up making a not account that I use to subscribe to random communities I might have a fleeting interest in, but don’t want in my subscribed feed.
So in my case I am the only user on my instance so I am certainly not going to be hammering a bunch of instances just to send me updates of whatever total number of communities I’m subscribed to.
You don’t understand how federated replication works. It doesn’t occur on-demand when you read a post, it occurs when the instance hosting the community gets a post, comment, or vote. The federation load you place on other servers has nothing to do with how many users are on your instance or how much they read… it has everything to do with how many communities they subscribe to. This script is literally signing you up to proactively receive the firehose of every post and comment in the lemmyverse, without regard for what you actually look at.
I completely understand the idea of the app, and your confusion about how much load it generates is exactly why it’s such an irresponsible idea. If you want to fill the timeline of your small instance, do so by subscribing to specific communities you’re interested in until your timeline becomes active enough for you. Subscribing to 100 communities you care about will result in a very lively feed of stuff that is interesting to you, while generating a tiny percentage of the federation load this approach does. Carpet bombing the entire lemmyverse with subscriptions you cannot read is madness. It’s like writing a reddit app that downloads everything ever posted to reddit to your phone to save you the trouble of picking subreddits to follow. It’s bad for reddit, bad for your phone, bad for your isp, and a bad idea all around. If I were running a large instance, I’d defederate with any tiny instance I observed subscribing indiscriminately via this script. It’s abuse.
I hear ya and I’m open to learning, but your way I have to still use another instance to be exposed to new communities. In essence I can’t have a Reddit “all” page… Is that correct?
There’s no such thing as an “all” page in Lemmy or on Reddit.
Even on a big server like lemmy.world we don’t see everything in the “all” feed. Beehaw defederated with us, and some new/small communities haven’t had anyone subscribe to them. These are missing from the “all” feed.
/r/all isn’t everything on Reddit either. It’s missing nsfw subreddits since 2021, all private subreddits, and who knows what else is filtered. It’s a curated selection of top posts to form a “frontpage” for those who haven’t built up their subscribed feed yet.
On a private Lemmy instance you are the admin and must curate your own frontpage. Community discovery on Lemmy does kind of suck right now, hopefully it will get better over time. For now, Lemmyverse.net is a good place to discover new communities, and you can browse the incomplete “all” feed of a major instance without an account there. Another responder in this thread suggested creating a dummy account to subscribe to stuff you want to see in your all feed but not in your subscribed feed… and it’s fine to do that kind of thing liberally. But it should be a human selected list of finite length. Indiscriminate subscription is bad all around.
You’re not the first person to want an /r/all, https://lemmy.directory/ tried. You can still see the announcement at https://lemmy.world/post/21875. It is now, less than one month later… broken. I’ll leave you to speculate on why and how you plan to avoid whatever problem shut them down.
Subscribing to 100 communities you care about will result in a very lively feed of stuff that is interesting to you, while generating a tiny percentage of the federation load this approach does.
It was a lot of work, but this is what I did (not 100 communities, but enough). I browser all on lemmy.world for days, finding communities I wanted to subscribe to. Then I subscribed to those on my account on my private instance. When I want more communities, I go back to lemmy.world and find more.
You are not logged in. However you can subscribe from another Fediverse account, for example Lemmy or Mastodon. To do this, paste the following into the search field of your instance: !selfhosted@lemmy.world
A place to share alternatives to popular online services that can be self-hosted without giving up privacy or locking you into a service you don’t control.
Rules:
Be civil: we’re here to support and learn from one another. Insults won’t be tolerated. Flame wars are frowned upon.
No spam posting.
Posts have to be centered around self-hosting. There are other communities for discussing hardware or home computing. If it’s not obvious why your post topic revolves around selfhosting, please include details to make it clear.
Don’t duplicate the full text of your blog or github here. Just post the link for folks to click.
Submission headline should match the article title (don’t cherry-pick information from the title to fit your agenda).
No trolling.
Resources:
selfh.st Newsletter and index of selfhosted software and apps
The idea of this app, which is desperately needed, is to allow those of us that are running a very small private instance to still get access to all of the communities. If you have a decent user base then you don’t need this anymore as the users themselves will provide the functionality.
So in my case I am the only user on my instance so I am certainly not going to be hammering a bunch of instances just to send me updates of whatever total number of communities I’m subscribed to.
I also wanted something like this, but I don’t want every single community. I ended up making a not account that I use to subscribe to random communities I might have a fleeting interest in, but don’t want in my subscribed feed.
You don’t understand how federated replication works. It doesn’t occur on-demand when you read a post, it occurs when the instance hosting the community gets a post, comment, or vote. The federation load you place on other servers has nothing to do with how many users are on your instance or how much they read… it has everything to do with how many communities they subscribe to. This script is literally signing you up to proactively receive the firehose of every post and comment in the lemmyverse, without regard for what you actually look at.
I completely understand the idea of the app, and your confusion about how much load it generates is exactly why it’s such an irresponsible idea. If you want to fill the timeline of your small instance, do so by subscribing to specific communities you’re interested in until your timeline becomes active enough for you. Subscribing to 100 communities you care about will result in a very lively feed of stuff that is interesting to you, while generating a tiny percentage of the federation load this approach does. Carpet bombing the entire lemmyverse with subscriptions you cannot read is madness. It’s like writing a reddit app that downloads everything ever posted to reddit to your phone to save you the trouble of picking subreddits to follow. It’s bad for reddit, bad for your phone, bad for your isp, and a bad idea all around. If I were running a large instance, I’d defederate with any tiny instance I observed subscribing indiscriminately via this script. It’s abuse.
You should write something that detects indiscriminate subscribing and automatically defederates with them.
I hear ya and I’m open to learning, but your way I have to still use another instance to be exposed to new communities. In essence I can’t have a Reddit “all” page… Is that correct?
There’s no such thing as an “all” page in Lemmy or on Reddit.
lemmy.worldwe don’t see everything in the “all” feed. Beehaw defederated with us, and some new/small communities haven’t had anyone subscribe to them. These are missing from the “all” feed.On a private Lemmy instance you are the admin and must curate your own frontpage. Community discovery on Lemmy does kind of suck right now, hopefully it will get better over time. For now, Lemmyverse.net is a good place to discover new communities, and you can browse the incomplete “all” feed of a major instance without an account there. Another responder in this thread suggested creating a dummy account to subscribe to stuff you want to see in your all feed but not in your subscribed feed… and it’s fine to do that kind of thing liberally. But it should be a human selected list of finite length. Indiscriminate subscription is bad all around.
You’re not the first person to want an /r/all, https://lemmy.directory/ tried. You can still see the announcement at https://lemmy.world/post/21875. It is now, less than one month later… broken. I’ll leave you to speculate on why and how you plan to avoid whatever problem shut them down.
It was a lot of work, but this is what I did (not 100 communities, but enough). I browser all on lemmy.world for days, finding communities I wanted to subscribe to. Then I subscribed to those on my account on my private instance. When I want more communities, I go back to lemmy.world and find more.
What?