Late Friday, a spokesperson confirmed the organization was investigating 600 of its workers suspected of 'inappropriately' receiving the $2,000-per-month CERB
The criteria was clearly defined on the website at the time. I remember looking it up, and I didn’t qualify, so I didn’t apply.
How did people apply without seeing the criteria written out on the page they were applying on? I guess some people were thinking “free money!” and didn’t bother to read the page.
The goal was to make sure people got the money they needed and they didn’t have the resources to look over the applications closely. Justin Trudeau clearly said something to the effect of “Yes it’s possible to get the CERB if you don’t actually qualify, but don’t that.”
It was very clear to me at the time that
a) I didn’t qualify
b) I could apply anyway and get the money even though I didn’t qualify
c) They would be checking later and I’d have to pay it back if I didn’t qualify
I think people got thinking about part b) and didn’t understand part c) would happen someday.
I was confused that I got a CERB clawback warning, and had it clawed back, but then I realized that I applied for sickness EI for something unrelated during covid. It isn’t worth it for me to try and track it back, especially when blinking the wrong direction is liable to get me locked out of my Service Canada account for some reason.
I just can’t even get angry about the ineptitude anymore, or even disappointed. Disappointment implies that I expected better, which throughout my apprenticeship of dealing with them I learned never to do.
They are saying they over paid me $1000 and are trying to be scary in attempting to retrieve it. Just making it difficult for them, as it wasn’t my fuck up.
I have no idea what it said on the website because, at the time, I had no internet at home, the library was closed and there are no public access points anywhere around. So I did what I always do, make application over the phone. That was a disaster zone of incomplete, incorrect, inconsistent, and occasionally incoherent instructions and alternate phone numbers.
Based on the fact that nobody has come chasing me for money, I’m guessing that I must have legitimately qualified.
Most people lack basic research skills in the best of times, and the start of the COVID pandemic was not the best of times. A lot of people were in situations where receiving CERB would have made sense, as in they definitely needed it, yet they were not technically eligible. I can’t really blame someone who’s stressed out, socially isolated, and out of a job seeing a program to help people through the pandemic and automatically applying, thinking “This must apply to me!”
I think people that were working for the CRA probably should’ve known they weren’t eligible. They had a job at the time. And part of that job was to know about this kind of thing. Either they’ve been fired for trying to rip off the government or they were fired for being incompetent at their jobs. Either way, it’s correct they were fired.
For others that made a mistake, they gotta pay the money back. So in the end they got a loan from the government. I don’t that as a bad thing either.
Not all government employees are full time indeterminates and not all CRA employees work in money related jobs. Heck, CERB wasn’t handled by them alone, service Canada also made payments! If their contract expired or was ended early then what? When CERB was introduced communication wasn’t clear at all and even some employers thought people should apply for that instead of EI.
How could the be fired now if their contract expired in 2020?
Why were employers telling their former employees to not apply for EI? Why were people who lost their jobs listening to what their former employer telling them to do?
“We need to let you go but from what we understand you need to apply for CERB instead of EI”
As for the first question, term employees are usually rehired again and again with breaks between contracts so they don’t reach their 3 years of continuous employment making them indeterminate by default. My bet is that many just went on CERB instead of EI and now they’re in trouble because of that.
One of the biggest problems with CERB was that you didn’t have to apply for it specifically.
I happened to be out of work for a short time and applied for regular EI. They automatically gave me CERB then fucked me over with a surprise $2k bill a year later.
Same for me, I think I had a short sickness EI claim automatically converted them clawed back, but because of the time gap involved I just couldn’t figure it out until now and figured that some money must have got dropped in my account without me noticing.
Yeah, I remember helping people look up the rules. JT was very clear, as was everyone else involved in the program. The point was helping people who needed it now^1. There was no verification at the time. They would go through and identify those who didn’t qualify later, when the emergency had passed.
I have little sympathy for people who were fully employed at the time, applied, and then play dumb. Sure, if you were on some modified work schedule or work sharing thing… it was a weird time. People could have been confused. It was always 100% clear from the start that it was meant from those who were being furloughed, laid off, put on unpaid leave, etc.
You are not logged in. However you can subscribe from another Fediverse account, for example Lemmy or Mastodon. To do this, paste the following into the search field of your instance: !canada@lemmy.ca
The criteria was clearly defined on the website at the time. I remember looking it up, and I didn’t qualify, so I didn’t apply.
How did people apply without seeing the criteria written out on the page they were applying on? I guess some people were thinking “free money!” and didn’t bother to read the page.
The goal was to make sure people got the money they needed and they didn’t have the resources to look over the applications closely. Justin Trudeau clearly said something to the effect of “Yes it’s possible to get the CERB if you don’t actually qualify, but don’t that.”
It was very clear to me at the time that a) I didn’t qualify b) I could apply anyway and get the money even though I didn’t qualify c) They would be checking later and I’d have to pay it back if I didn’t qualify
I think people got thinking about part b) and didn’t understand part c) would happen someday.
I applied for EI as I qualified for that, they gave me CERB instead.
Did they end up clawing it back?
I was confused that I got a CERB clawback warning, and had it clawed back, but then I realized that I applied for sickness EI for something unrelated during covid. It isn’t worth it for me to try and track it back, especially when blinking the wrong direction is liable to get me locked out of my Service Canada account for some reason.
I just can’t even get angry about the ineptitude anymore, or even disappointed. Disappointment implies that I expected better, which throughout my apprenticeship of dealing with them I learned never to do.
They are saying they over paid me $1000 and are trying to be scary in attempting to retrieve it. Just making it difficult for them, as it wasn’t my fuck up.
I have no idea what it said on the website because, at the time, I had no internet at home, the library was closed and there are no public access points anywhere around. So I did what I always do, make application over the phone. That was a disaster zone of incomplete, incorrect, inconsistent, and occasionally incoherent instructions and alternate phone numbers.
Based on the fact that nobody has come chasing me for money, I’m guessing that I must have legitimately qualified.
Most people lack basic research skills in the best of times, and the start of the COVID pandemic was not the best of times. A lot of people were in situations where receiving CERB would have made sense, as in they definitely needed it, yet they were not technically eligible. I can’t really blame someone who’s stressed out, socially isolated, and out of a job seeing a program to help people through the pandemic and automatically applying, thinking “This must apply to me!”
I think people that were working for the CRA probably should’ve known they weren’t eligible. They had a job at the time. And part of that job was to know about this kind of thing. Either they’ve been fired for trying to rip off the government or they were fired for being incompetent at their jobs. Either way, it’s correct they were fired.
For others that made a mistake, they gotta pay the money back. So in the end they got a loan from the government. I don’t that as a bad thing either.
Not all government employees are full time indeterminates and not all CRA employees work in money related jobs. Heck, CERB wasn’t handled by them alone, service Canada also made payments! If their contract expired or was ended early then what? When CERB was introduced communication wasn’t clear at all and even some employers thought people should apply for that instead of EI.
How could the be fired now if their contract expired in 2020?
Why were employers telling their former employees to not apply for EI? Why were people who lost their jobs listening to what their former employer telling them to do?
“We need to let you go but from what we understand you need to apply for CERB instead of EI”
As for the first question, term employees are usually rehired again and again with breaks between contracts so they don’t reach their 3 years of continuous employment making them indeterminate by default. My bet is that many just went on CERB instead of EI and now they’re in trouble because of that.
One of the biggest problems with CERB was that you didn’t have to apply for it specifically.
I happened to be out of work for a short time and applied for regular EI. They automatically gave me CERB then fucked me over with a surprise $2k bill a year later.
I just finished paying that off 2 months ago.
Same for me, I think I had a short sickness EI claim automatically converted them clawed back, but because of the time gap involved I just couldn’t figure it out until now and figured that some money must have got dropped in my account without me noticing.
Yeah, I remember helping people look up the rules. JT was very clear, as was everyone else involved in the program. The point was helping people who needed it now^1. There was no verification at the time. They would go through and identify those who didn’t qualify later, when the emergency had passed.
I have little sympathy for people who were fully employed at the time, applied, and then play dumb. Sure, if you were on some modified work schedule or work sharing thing… it was a weird time. People could have been confused. It was always 100% clear from the start that it was meant from those who were being furloughed, laid off, put on unpaid leave, etc.
^1 Well not now now, but then now.