“We don’t think that censorship (including through demonetizing publications) makes the problem go away.”
Butterbee (She/Her)
link
fedilink
English
1610M

Look. If there are 9 people at a table sitting with 1 Nazi and hanging out, there are 10 Nazis.

@jarfil@beehaw.org
link
fedilink
3
edit-2
10M

That’s the quick, easy, and wrong approach.

What are 9 non-Nazi people supposed to do: kick the 1 Nazi to a Nazi-only table? Leave the table and now have 2 Nazi-only tables? Get everyone thrown out?

Nazism works like any other sect; what converted people need, is exposure to other ways of thinking, ideally some human connections with people whom the sect demonizes and tries to keep members away from. Pushing sect members away from society, is precisely what the sect wants!

I’m not saying that you personally, or even me, should be the ones to do that, or that we should idly watch, or not have a Nazi-free table.

What I’m saying is that non-Nazis putting up with a Nazi in order to de-program them, should be praised, and that you can’t tell what’s really going on just by watching who sits where.

Butterbee (She/Her)
link
fedilink
English
910M

This is too complex and nuanced. You punch the nazi and throw them out of the establishment. That’s it. That’s all.

That’s how you reinforce the indoctrination of “us vs. them”, and how they’re the oppressed ones. Far from “it” or “all”.

Butterbee (She/Her)
link
fedilink
English
910M

Yes. I don’t care if they feel oppressed. Tolerance does not extend to Nazis. They SHOULD feel oppressed. I will not entertain being soft on Nazis. I will not entertain “seeing both sides”. I will not entertain Nazis.

@jarfil@beehaw.org
link
fedilink
3
edit-2
10M

I don’t think you understand. Instilling a feeling of oppression, then a desire to “fight against the oppression”, is how Nazis get created. Nobody’s asking you to tolerate it, or see any “both sides”, there are no sides. The only side is whether you work with or against their indoctrination.

All I’m saying is you better double check those 9 other people at that table, in case they’re doing the hard work you or me don’t want to.

I just want to state very emphatically that deradicalizing people is a specific skill set and set of actions that is completely different than “being friendly to nazis”. And tolerating bigotry so that people don’t feel bad about their bigotry is just tolerating bigotry. On that note, on another post you argued heavily with multiple users that white privilege is not real and that you were being oppressed for your whiteness. I thought maybe you were very young, or confused, and tried to have empathy and explain some concepts, but here you are now also arguing that we need to be nice to nazis for the good of society so that they don’t feel oppressed. I suppose you might say that pointing this out and making you feel more oppressed would drive you further away, but a better approach, i think, would be to tell you very very directly that the things you have been saying here, in multiple places, are white supremacist talking points. And no one here is going to condone that. Stop. If you need help stopping, that is your responsibility, not the hypothetical 9 other peoples’.

@jarfil@beehaw.org
link
fedilink
2
edit-2
10M

How can you tell “deradicalizing” from “being friendly” by just seeing people sit at the same table? One of the strategies for deradicalization, is precisely having positive experiences with people the group/sect has vilified.

here you are now also arguing that we need to be nice to nazis

No. In a nazi-free area, just kick the nazi, that’s easy. What I’m arguing is that you should give the benefit of the doubt to the other 9 people. Don’t assume.


on another post you argued heavily with multiple users that white privilege is not real

Let me clear that up:

  • White privilege is real. So are others.
  • I’ve always tried to avoid using my privileges.
  • People assuming I’m too privileged have fucked me over.

These are not either-or.

I thought maybe you were very young, or confused, and tried to have empathy and explain some concepts

Not very young, maybe confused, maybe living in a different society, most likely with different life experiences.

Thank you for trying to explain some concepts. I learned some stuff in that other post, and I’m grateful for that (even if the conclusion was depressing).

the things you have been saying here, in multiple places, are white supremacist talking points

If you need help stopping, that is your responsibility

Is this another “learn the book of forbidden words” situation?

I refused to read into white supremacist propaganda any further than seeing their basic manipulation strategies, and that was a few decades ago. Are you asking me to read the updated version?

Over the past several days I’ve seen you draw out many good faith disagreements about racism or nazism into what seem like intentionally blurry “just asking questions” type derailments whereby you try to shift the topic of the discussion to other, emotional or tangential details and or try to misrepresent the issue at hand to make the racism or nazism seem not that bad. I really don’t think someone would do that if they were coming from a place of genuine confusion or curiosity or dialogue. I might be wrong, but taken together it really gives the impression, intent aside, that you’re trying to spin up plausible arguments for far right stuff and then sow confusion whenever people say “hey, don’t do that, it’s harmful”. I just don’t believe there’s wiggle room here. I don’t want to have a circular conversation about it, but i do want to point out directly what you’re doing, because I think it sucks, and I think that you should stop.

No. In a nazi-free area, just kick the nazi, that’s easy. What I’m arguing is that you should give the benefit of the doubt to the other 9 people. Don’t assume.

All areas should be nazi-free areas. If any of them are truly attempting to de-radicalize someone they would know that there is a time and place for it, and out in general society is not it.

Is this another “learn the book of forbidden words” situation?

This is very reductive, dismissive and exactly the kind of thing a white supremacist would say to try and justify saying something shitty. Which is exactly PotentiallyAnApricot’s point. I could chock it up to naivety, but just as an outside observer on this thread and others, I don’t think it is.

I refused to read into white supremacist propaganda any further than seeing their basic manipulation strategies, and that was a few decades ago. Are you asking me to read the updated version?

Dismantling systemic oppression personally, interpersonally, and in greater society is a constant process. Especially as a white person. Saying you did some research decades ago and are all good now is not how it works.

Butterbee (She/Her)
link
fedilink
English
810M

I think I may not have made my position clear. If there is 1 Nazi at the table, and 9 people are just sitting with them hanging out… you have 10 Nazis. They are not “doing the hard work” otherwise it the 1 Nazi would not be sitting there. I’m hearing a lot of sympathizing towards Nazis in this thread.

You have made your position very clear, but if what you got from what I’m saying is “sympathizing towards Nazis”, then you’ve missed my point completely, and I don’t know how to make it any clearer. 🤷

Create a post

A nice place to discuss rumors, happenings, innovations, and challenges in the technology sphere. We also welcome discussions on the intersections of technology and society. If it’s technological news or discussion of technology, it probably belongs here.

Remember the overriding ethos on Beehaw: Be(e) Nice. Each user you encounter here is a person, and should be treated with kindness (even if they’re wrong, or use a Linux distro you don’t like). Personal attacks will not be tolerated.

Subcommunities on Beehaw:


This community’s icon was made by Aaron Schneider, under the CC-BY-NC-SA 4.0 license.

  • 1 user online
  • 61 users / day
  • 171 users / week
  • 620 users / month
  • 2.31K users / 6 months
  • 1 subscriber
  • 3.28K Posts
  • 67K Comments
  • Modlog