Seriously.

I never used brave. I wasn’t interested in it since I learned it was chromium and all the crypto stuff.

Melllvar
link
fedilink
English
1131Y

Why was appointing Eich as CEO so controversial? It’s because he donated $1,000 in support of California’s Proposition 8 in 2008, which was a proposed amendment to California’s state constitution to ban same-sex marriage.

Which is all the reason I need.

They had me at invented JavaScript

@kent_eh@lemmy.ca
link
fedilink
English
341Y

If he had changed his tune since then and done something to offset that, I might be willing to cut him some slack.

But, instead, he seems to have doubled down…

Are there any brave forks that throw out all the bullshit? Bold browser seems pretty dead

This is madness. How does this keep getting upvoted when the article has nothing to do with the actual code integrity and functionality of this browser.

At least it’s open source, if there is something shady point it out in the code.

The moment my cryptofan buddy started talking up brave, I knew it was time to uninstall.

I’m pretty sure I’ve read this news a couple of times now the past week or weeks?

YⓄ乙
link
fedilink
41Y

Can someone please fork brave?

Which feature do you want that isn’t already in better, Firefox-based browsers?

YⓄ乙
link
fedilink
11Y

Lol seriously? I am using firefox from past 5, -8 years and never crashed once.

YⓄ乙
link
fedilink
11Y

When visiting the govt. Website, it says you’re using unsupported browser and some feature won’t work but when I use brave, I dont get that message.

sane tab management and behavior on mobile versions along with proper syncing is apparently too huge of a hurdle to handle for the devs. these two are pretty much the only reason why i still use brave and not firefox

DarkenLM
link
fedilink
31Y

Not crashing my computer after using it for a few minutes would be nice.

@Uniquitous@lemmy.one
link
fedilink
English
91Y

What the hell kind of rickety rig are you running?

deleted by creator

DarkenLM
link
fedilink
21Y

Not Mac OS, but I am using a linux distro, and can confirm it’s Firefox, as I’ve reinstalled everything from scratch and only Firefox seems to have this problem.

I use brave because it doesn’t apply chrome or edge group policies. If someone can tell me a better chromium based Browser (or firefox based) that does this, I’m all ears…

TWeaK
link
fedilink
English
151Y

From another user:

Firefox:

Chrome:

Also Mull for Android, with Mulch for Android System Webview.

Isn’t this like the fourth time this has been posted? the conversation always goes around in circles with nobody changing their mind.

I love Brave, use it daily, and this article didn’t convince me at all. Vaguely motioning at the founder’s ancient political donations or the optional crypto features, doesn’t make a strong case.

Chromium should be enough of a reason to get rid of it.

You have the choice between the engine made by Google and the engine paid for by Google.

Brave at least has its own search engine, something Mozilla doesn’t even dare, as that’s where they get all their Google money from.

snowe
link
fedilink
41Y

Or there’s Safari or Orion, neither of which are what you listed. Also, Firefox is not “paid for by google” they get funding through their nonprofit as well.

Also, Firefox is not “paid for by google”

Around 85% of the $450 million they get each year come from Google.

Scary le Poo
link
fedilink
11Y

It’s not like google is guiding their development processes, come off of this horseshit.

Just because you like Brave the search engine doesn’t mean you have to use Brave the browser. The two have no inherent connection.

Edit: While we’re on the subject of money, I’d be more worried about that Peter Thiel money Brave took. That man openly claims freedom and democracy to be incompatible and supports efforts to create independent libertarian societies on international waters and in space.

I use brave search from firefox, seems the least shitty search engine so far.

Nothing against brave the browser, I’ve just been using firefox for about 10 years so have a lot of inertia.

something Mozilla doesn’t even dare, as that’s where they get all their Google money from

Or because they’re aware that it’d be a huge waste of time and money? It’d be a lot of work to build a search engine anywhere near as good as the existing alternatives, so it’d give worse user experience and waste time.

It’d be a lot of work to build a search engine anywhere near as good as the existing alternatives,

And yet Brave Search has done so. You got to have to come up with better excuses for Mozilla’s failure here.

Scary le Poo
link
fedilink
21Y

Mozilla pushes DuckDuckGo. That is a feature, not a failure.

How exactly are they pushing DuckDuckGo by making Google the default? And anyway, DuckDuckGo is just a wrapper around Bing, so that’s not even much of an improvement.

Yeah this article is not very convincing

Brave is great! No ads, Tor built in, and can install Chrome extensions. I don’t use their crypto wallet and it’s never bothered me

@Hyperi0n@lemmy.film
link
fedilink
English
71Y

Ad will be injected soon. Tor is not built in.

Tor is not built in

Source? I’ve used Tor with Brave

I use brave and think it’s the best browser available, so I’m not arguing against it or anything, but technically it just supports use of the onion protocol, it does not provide the same full suite of protections that the tor browser does

As Brave says themselves:

For users who currently require leakproof privacy, we recommend using the Tor Browser, which provides much stronger and well-tested protection against websites or eavesdroppers using advanced techniques to uncover a true IP address.

https://brave.com/tor-tabs-beta/

@Hyperi0n@lemmy.film
link
fedilink
English
81Y

You’ve used onion links. Brave implemented unsecured onion protocol in thier Chromium browser.

Anything using Firefox as a base can run onion links with a simple add on because Tor is just Firefox. Vivaldi comes with onion support right out of the box, doesn’t support hate and is malware free.

You see, when someone is known to make bad choices it makes sense to approach what they do with apprehension. This guy not only has a history of bad choices, he’s also the CEO.

You’re free to do as you like of course, but I’d say it’s hardly fair to say the article is unconvincing.

Depends. As long as he doesn’t rub it in my face by putting it into the browser, I don’t care much. So I understand people who are pissed off because crypto is being rubbed in your face with Brave. But since I can disable that (and disabling it syncs to my other devices), I am also fine with that.

In return I get a browser where I like the sync model, with integrated Tor private browsing mode, and which is based on Chromium (which has sadly still the best dev tools, IMO).

Even MS Edge has some nice features and I used it for a while (I very much like that you can specify in which browser profile you want to open external links in). But they started to put more and more of their Microsoft bullshit into it with each version trying to sell me on all the different fucked up services they offer. Saying “no” once or twice: no problem. Saying “no” every fucking time they update the browser: fuck off.

Given their crypto functionality uses a third party which has been found to skirt the legal system I’d be a lot more concerned about this integration even if I don’t intend to use it.

Keep in mind the stuff you read about is only what has been surfaced so far. Who knows what skeletons are still hiding?

Personally, I don’t see any point risking it when there are perfectly viable alternatives such as Firefox. Granted the same guy infected Mozilla, but they stood up and ousted him so credit where credit is due.

Given their crypto functionality uses a third party which has been found to skirt the legal system I’d be a lot more concerned about this integration even if I don’t intend to use it.

They offered a tenuous high yield lending program, that the SEC only jumped on after it collapsed from the FTX contagion. Litigation is pending afaik and depends on whether the program qualifies as a security, but the SEC has been losing ground in their optimistic claims of what they think qualifies as a security (outcome of Ripple lawsuit etc.).

Don’t get me wrong, any such program is sketchy and I trust Gemini less for having offered it, but IMO it doesn’t put them on the same tier as an exchange like FTX or make me think they would inject malware into software they have a connection with.

Yeah that’s fair. I’d say it falls into the same boat as the argument against the CEO; they haven’t done anything clearly malicious, but their bad decisions are enough to give you pause and reconsider.

Madis
link
fedilink
4
edit-2
1Y

Who knows what skeletons are still hiding?

Go and have a look? https://github.com/brave/brave-browser

My argument is that Brave is a Chromium browser with questionable business goals, but it is also the most private and secure, open-source, mainstream* Chromium browser. These keywords cannot be said about Vivaldi, Ungoogled Chromium and many other projects unfortunately.

That said, I primarily use Vivaldi because of its customizability and added features, something Firefox seems to reduce with every new version.

  • Not quite on Edge or Opera level, and no accurate data can be found due to the removal of unique user agent, but nonetheless I’d argue it is more popular than others of similar kind.
@Naatan@lemmy.one
link
fedilink
5
edit-2
1Y

Go and have a look? https://github.com/brave/brave-browser

Being open-source doesn’t automatically make you secure or reputable. Especially considering the open-source ecosystem in particular is a big target for exploitation right now. And auditing a software project of this size by its source code alone is no small feat.

it is also the most private and secure, open-source, mainstream* Chromium browser

“Mainstream chromium browser” is doing most if not all the heavy lifting there. Fair enough if that’s what you’re after, but mixing “private and secure, open-source” in feels disingenuous.

That said, I primarily use Vivaldi because of its customizability and added features, something Firefox seems to reduce with every new version.

Last time I played with either Vivaldi or Brave you had to literally monkey patch the source code in order to customize things further than what the extension SDK allowed you to. You could do the same thing with Firefox, except they make it slightly harder because much of the source code is shipped in archives.

That said it’s been years, maybe this can now be done purely through the extension SDK? It’d be news to me.

Wugmeister
link
fedilink
71Y

removed by mod

davehtaylor
link
fedilink
321Y

“Just learned about this company that’s led by a raging bigot who has used his wealth and position to try to oppress others and strip them of civil and human rights, and I fully support that and am now a proud supporter”

@Hyperi0n@lemmy.film
link
fedilink
English
51Y

They also sell userdata more than Google, have installed malware knowingly and thier shitcoin skirts the law.

Melllvar
link
fedilink
English
951Y

2008 is not ancient. Nor is same-sex marriage some minor technical legal point.

Nor has he repented.

@kent_eh@lemmy.ca
link
fedilink
English
401Y

Nor has he repented.

That’s the important point for me.

People can change after 20 years. But he prefers to double-down instead.

So? He’s the CEO of a company that already gets no money from me.

Online forums pick the weirdest hills to die on sometimes. You’ve probably used hundreds of products today alone made by companies whose CEOs are worse dickwads than Eich. But this gave you a chance to feel superior online so you had to take it lmao

Melllvar
link
fedilink
English
27
edit-2
1Y

As a gay Californian, I took prop 8 personally. I spurn its supporters as I would spurn a rabid dog.

There is nothing wrong with Brave. It’s a great browser. I like the cryptocurrency aspect of it.

@Uniquitous@lemmy.one
link
fedilink
English
431Y

Crypto is a scam and you’re being duped.

“Crytpto” is not a scam. Bitcoin and Ethereum are the future of money.

There are a lot of shitcoins out there, but don’t let them fool you into staying poor. Fiat money is dying.

@Uniquitous@lemmy.one
link
fedilink
English
271Y

All money is fiat money. It has an agreed upon value outside of its intrinsic worth. If you want to get away from fiat money you have to go back to barter.

That’s not true. Fiat money is money created and managed by a government. We need separation of State and Money.

from The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, 5th Edition.

noun Legal tender, especially paper currency, authorized by a government but not based on or convertible into gold or silver.

from Wiktionary, Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike License.

noun economics Money that is given legal value or made legal tender for money debts by government fiat.

from WordNet 3.0 Copyright 2006 by Princeton University. All rights reserved.

noun money that the government declares to be legal tender although it cannot be converted into standard speci
@Uniquitous@lemmy.one
link
fedilink
English
271Y

So you prefer your currency to backed by the full faith and credit of… nobody? And you think you’re not being duped. Hilarious.

It’s backed by math. There is a fixed amount of Bitcoin. We have never had the concept of “digital scarcity” before. There are thousands of computers running independently that are following a consensus algorithm. it’s an open, permisionless, trustless system that anyone on the planet can be part of.

You would rather have money controlled by corrupt governments? Hilarious.

Baut [she/her] auf.
link
fedilink
5
edit-2
1Y

digital scarcity

ipv4 addresses. Also bitcoin is the worst example here, as it’s just an asset. It’s not bearable as real money, you can’t trust its always changing value. It’s also a victim of constant market manipulation. XMR on the other hand is a relatively stable currency.
Bitcoin is also a privacy and ecological nightmare.
In general it’s also really fun that you can lose all your money without doing anything wrong.

@beefcat@beehaw.org
link
fedilink
28
edit-2
1Y

There is a fixed amount of Bitcoin.

That is part of the problem. As long as the economy grows, then Bitcoin is deflationary. This encourages people who have it to hoard it, rather than to move it around and drive the economy. It is almost perfectly designed to be used as a speculative investment rather than an actual day-to-day currency.

Having a fixed pool of money to represent your economy only makes sense if the total value of the economy will never change. This doesn’t happen in the real world. Populations grow, new technologies add value, and poverty generally goes down. This is all fairly simple math.

@Uniquitous@lemmy.one
link
fedilink
English
111Y

Ah, I see, you think that because you can mint Schmecklebux or whatever and use it as a medium of exchange, you’re somehow exempt from the laws of whatever country you’re in when the trade goes down? Tell me, does your flag have a fringe on it?

Turun
link
fedilink
3
edit-2
1Y

I think crypto could have its place as the cash of the internet. No one can watch your transaction, but if the other person takes your money and runs you are shit outta luck. No way to revert transactions, perfect for money laundering, but also anonymous, which can be a plus.

But all this makes it completely unsuitable in everyday use.

Also: yes, there is a fixed amount of Bitcoin. But you know what governments all over the world did when Inflation was sky high? Change the interest rates to change the amount of money that goes into the economy to make everyday items affordable again.

And for Bitcoin in particular, if everyone actually uses it as intended the artificial limit of the transaction rate would only allow you to perform one transaction every two yearsor something like that.

davehtaylor
link
fedilink
101Y

It’s backed by math.

No, it’s backed by the power grid. Shut off the power, and you have nothing.

Also trying to create scarcity in a realm where none actually exists shows how greedy and scammy it is.

It’s worse than any other fiat currency. There’s literally nothing behind it.

you should read “what is money” by mitchel innes. he shows very well that pretty much any money ever has been fiat money

@HalJor@beehaw.org
link
fedilink
English
4
edit-2
1Y

Fiat money via WIkipedia:

Fiat money can be:
* Any money that is not backed by a commodity.
* Money declared by a person, institution or government to be legal tender,[5] meaning that it must be accepted in payment of a debt in specific circumstances.[6]
* State-issued money which is neither convertible through a central bank to anything else nor fixed in value in terms of any objective standard.[7]
* Money used because of government decree.[2]
* An otherwise non-valuable object that serves as a medium of exchange[8] (also known as fiduciary money).[9]

Doesn’t have to come from a government. Crypto is three of these. The article even starts with “Fiat money is a type of currency that is not backed by a commodity, such as gold or silver.” Nothing about government there either.

at this point we are just arguing over semantics.

@HalJor@beehaw.org
link
fedilink
English
31Y

The differences and implications are important, and it’s hard to make a convincing argument if your base premise is incorrect.

Crypto is a dead end at best, a scam at worst. I mined for years and can’t believe I drank the koolaid tbh

Pwrsonally I don’t use Brave due to it being chromium, outside of that itis a good browser. If they were a firefox fork I would absolutely use them.

I love firefox. It’s my main browser for everything. When I need a chrome based browser for testing things, Brave is my go to browser.

Yepp, I started just using vanilla chromium though instead, as that offers a barebones option to guarantee I don’t need to mess around to test something works.

Brave has built in ad-blocking that is good to test against. One of our tools wasn’t able to submit new issues to jira because atlassian.net was being blocked by the browser.

“What if Chromium had its own fake money?”

Money is a social construct that only has value because people agree it has value. Bitcoin and Ethereum are the best forms of money humans have ever invented. Once we have privacy at the base layer, fiat money is dead.

Ha. Hu ha ha. Ha. Hahaha.

Money has value because it is an efficient medium to facilitate trade. Specific forms of money have value because of what backs it and it acts as a medium for trade. And yeah I’m sure what society really values will at some point be a money that limits the ability to deal with economic crises. Or that slowly disappears, because privacy Bob didn’t believe in banks but his SSD failed, or because Crypto Karen forgot her password. Or a hacker loots an exchange.

I mean, it’s not like those are fundamental problems that could bring an economy to it’s knees right? But hey, at least the money has privacy (it won’t) and we don’t have to worry about inflation (deflation on the other hand…).

Cryptocurrency is the most efficient money we have. It doesn’t require any middle man bankers. Sure, hackers can hack and loot exchanges, but right now we have the government looting us with inflation.

The problems you mentioned are being worked on. There are ways to backup and restore your wallet that will become easy.

The global economy doesn’t need to only rely on Bitcoin, so the argument that we have to worry about deflation is just wrong.

This is the wild west of innovation. Scammers like money, so of course they will be attracted to cyrptocurrency. They are also very attracted to fiat currency.

All of the references on that page have to do with random NFT projects and shitcoins.

You should try to separate the concept of “Crypto” from the concept of base layer blockchain protocols that actually have value.

TWeaK
link
fedilink
English
91Y

There is plenty wrong with Brave, the business.

Brave, the browser, is very useful in a practical sense. It has some nice features out of the box, and if you disable the naughty out of the box features it’s pretty decent. However, you have to trust that each update from the developer is good, and past experience raises very serious questions with this particular business.

Maybe you might be seeing some returns from the cryptocurrency. My undestanding is that users have lost far more than they’ve gained - and that’s before you actually look into the true value of what users are sacrificing in exchange for their tokens. Meanwhile, Brave are pulling a steady revenue making money from their users, milking them just so.

you like baked in ads, crypto, falsely using people to promote your browser… oof

The browser works well. I am very much into crytpocurrency. I think Bitcoin and Ethereum are the future of money.

You don’t need to turn on ads in Brave. It blocks ads really well.

I use Brave as a secondary browser mostly for government websites because sometimes my firefox privacy settings breaks them and since many of them are poorly designed a technical issue over your account may result in hours on the phone to resolve.

Why not use chromium or one of the many other chrome forks? What about Brave works better?

Because it works, has okay configurations out of the box, and I just don’t really care enough about the points mentioned in this article to make the switch. I only use it for cases where I don’t expect privacy like government websites. As soon as you open an account there they got all your info anyway.

we need a list of apps that incorporates chromium, otherwise i put sketchy apps in the app freezer to avoid them running in the background

@Hyperi0n@lemmy.film
link
fedilink
English
21Y

Steam is a huge one.

Apparently we need separate lists for pc and android. In android u could freeze apps, idk what could be the equivalent for it on pc(linux, win,…)

@whou wish someone else would build an easy to set up and use chromium browser for windows that blocks telemetry and isn’t run by an asshole… something i could get friends and family to use.

I used to think Brave was good until I found out they are into crypto.

Nope Nope and Nope! Not using that thing again. Firefox is my friend now.

Create a post

A nice place to discuss rumors, happenings, innovations, and challenges in the technology sphere. We also welcome discussions on the intersections of technology and society. If it’s technological news or discussion of technology, it probably belongs here.

Remember the overriding ethos on Beehaw: Be(e) Nice. Each user you encounter here is a person, and should be treated with kindness (even if they’re wrong, or use a Linux distro you don’t like). Personal attacks will not be tolerated.

Subcommunities on Beehaw:


This community’s icon was made by Aaron Schneider, under the CC-BY-NC-SA 4.0 license.

  • 1 user online
  • 144 users / day
  • 275 users / week
  • 709 users / month
  • 2.87K users / 6 months
  • 1 subscriber
  • 3.09K Posts
  • 64.9K Comments
  • Modlog